Episode 318

318 The Ugly vs Bland Episode

Are you tired of the same bland electric vehicles dominating the market? In this episode I dive into the design landscape of electric vehicles, exploring the critical question: would you prefer to drive an ugly car or a bland one? Join me as I reflect on my experiences with various cars, from the iconic Porsche 911 to the underwhelming ID3, and how car aesthetics have evolved.

The automotive industry is witnessing a fascinating bifurcation; some brands are producing striking, memorable designs while others stick to generic styles. I share insights on the emerging trendy EVs from renowned brands like Jaguar and Renault, known for their distinctive designs that evoke strong opinions—both positive and negative. You'll discover the latest trends in vehicle design, how manufacturers are responding to consumer desires for style, and the implications for the future of electric vehicles.

We break down how historical perspectives on vehicle design shape current trends and what it means for consumers today. I discuss the challenges faced by brands like Nissan and Honda, who are struggling to balance aesthetics and functionality while introducing new electric models.

Join me on this journey through the evolving world of electric vehicles and discover where the true beauty lies.

The EV Musings Podcast is sponsored by Zapmap, the go-to app for EV drivers, helping you find and pay for public charging with confidence.

(C) 2019-2026 Gary Comerford

Support me:

Patreon Link: http://www.patreon.com/evmusings

Ko-fi Link: http://www.ko-fi.com/evmusings

The Books:

'So, you've gone electric?' on Amazon : https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07Q5JVF1X

'So, you've gone renewable?’ on Amazon : https://amzn.to/3LXvIck

Social Media:

EVMusings: Twitter https://twitter.com/MusingsEv

Instagram: @EVmusings

Octopus Energy referral code (Click this link to get started) https://share.octopus.energy/neat-star-460

Upgrade to smarter EV driving with a free week's trial of Zapmap Premium, find out more here https://evmusings.com/zapmap-premium

Transcript
Gary Comerford (:

When I was young I drove a mini. It was cute, it was stylish, it was slow.

Gary Comerford (:

When I was young, I drove a mini. It was cute, it was stylish, it was slow. When I got a little older, I drove a Mark IV escort. It was comfortable, it was economic, it was slow. Then I bought a Porsche 911. It was iconic, it was stylish, it was fast, it was very expensive to run. And now I drive EVs. Some of them are really great. The Polestar looks cool and it drives really well.

Gary Comerford (:

The ID3 I had was, well, it looked fine, but it wasn't going to light the world on fire with its style. I've also driven quite a few Chinese cars. They've all been comfortable, feature packed, good value, and mostly bland. And today I want to talk about this and ask you a simple question. Would you rather drive an ugly car or a bland car?

Hi, I'm Gary, and this is EV Musings, a podcast about renewables, electric vehicles, and things that are interesting to electric vehicle owners. Now on the show today we'll be looking at EV design and why I think we're heading towards a sea of metaphorical beige.

Gary Comerford (:

Today's topic is something I've been mulling over for a while, and it's all to do with what's happening with the car brands here in Europe. We've basically got some sort of bifurcation with cars. Now, when I say bifurcation, I'm talking about a split into two, but I'm not talking about the EV versus fossil fuel, although that's certainly happening. Brands such as Tesla, BYD, and Polestar are producing electric-only vehicles for the most part, although BYD do have some hybrids in there. No, I'm talking about a split between stylish and not so stylish.

Gary Comerford (:

I remember when I was young and we started to get the first Japanese cars into the country. They were all reliable, easy to dre drive, they were all reliable, easy to drive, packed with features and incredibly soulless. I mean nobody can look at an original Toyota Corolla and think, yep, that's for me, I want to drive that for the rest of my life. I remember this was around about the time that cars like the early Porsche 911, the Jaguar E-Type Classic, and the classic Mini Cooper were all on the road. My mother drove a Nissan cherry for a few years.

Perfectly fine. But it looked a lot like a design student was given the brief. Make it as inoffensive as possible. Then the Korean cars came along. They too were good cars, well made, reliable, and functional. What about that warranty? But none of them set the world on fire when it came to design. Now, in certain segments of society, the Datsans and Nissans were referred to as Japanese boxcars. Nowadays, however, things are different. But not

That much different. The cars are still, for the most part, reliable, efficient, and functional. But very few of the NEV cars, the new energy vehicles from China, are setting the world on fire when it comes to design. I recently spent a week with a Chang'an Deepal SO5. Lovely car to drive, very comfortable, very reliable, very bland. The design was the generic SUV that seems to be coming out of China nowadays. See Leap Motors B10, BYD C Lion.

IonS V, XPEX G9L, the Skyworld B01, and many others. Now there's nothing intrinsically wrong with this, of course. As I mentioned earlier, many people drove around in Japanese boxcars for many years. They appreciated the reliability and the efficiency of the cars, even if they didn't turn heads while they were driving along the street. But something we're starting to see more and more nowadays is a movement towards less.

Bland cars. Some might call them stylish, some might call them ugly, but they're certainly not nondescript. Now, as with the historic vehicles of my youth, these design studies are coming from the traditional brands that existed prior to the Far East invasion. We've got the French brands, always known for their style. The French have produced iconic designs such as the original 2C V, the Renault 5, and the Citroen DS, all classics of the time. Now, sure.

Gary Comerford (:

A lot of them were unreliable and often spent more time in the service bay than on the road. Renault cars used be notorious for electrical faults, but they were great to look at and they showed an amount of flair. In England, we had the aforementioned Mini Cooper, the Jaguarie type, the Ford Capri. Germany had the Mercedes SLC Coupe and the BMW three series, proper driving machines. And of course, Porsche with the iconic 911 and to a lesser extent the Porsche 928. Both

Design masterpieces. Italy had the Alpha Range, the Fiat Cinquis Cinquecento, the Lancia Integrale, also classics of their time. Now, as I mentioned before, they might not have all been as reliable as you might have liked. I mean, the early alphas were prone to rusting, for example. And the design might not have been to your absolute liking. But they were all very striking, and you could never refer to them as bland. So that raises the question I asked you in the introduction: would you rather have a car?

That was ugly or a car that was bland. Now, in the spirit of full disclosure, those of you who listen to the podcast will know that my first electric vehicle was a 30 kilowatt hour Kia Sol EV. It was certainly a design that divided opinion. It was bulky, it was square, it came in colour options that I described as the smurf, the nurse, or the grey one. I had the grey one, but you could never describe them as bland. There's also the original Kia e Niro.

Friend of the show, Andrew Till, has one and he loves it. But on this very podcast, he described it as looking a bit like a hippo. And once you've seen that, you won't unsee it. So are we starting to turn a corner when it comes to designs, especially in EVs? To some extent, yes. In others, no. For the most part, the NEVs coming from the Far East, particularly China, are very generic and homogeneous.

For a lot of the European vehicles, there seems to be a move towards something that's a little more polarizing. Let's look at a couple of specific cases. JLR unveiled their Jaguar Type 01 recently. It's a Hulk in behemoth of a car that, in the original pink colour scheme, was derogatorily referred to as Lady Penelope's car from Thunderbirds. Ferrari launched the Luce to great acclaim recently, and not all of it positive.

Gary Comerford (:

It's Apple's EV, seemed to be the considered opinion. It's not a real Ferrari. I was at the launch in Paris recently of the Electric Citroen 2 CV. It's quirky, it's not particularly attractive, but then the original never was either. And the inside looks like it was put together by two friends trying to build a toy car using whatever they found in their father's shed. The colour scheme is interesting. A little further back in time, the revamped Renault 5 was launched to great acclaim. It looks a lot

itself a design icon from the:

Now these have all been well received and have helped push Renault to great heights when it comes to EV sales in Europe. But when you look at each of the cars mentioned above, they all have one thing in common that distinguishes them from the NEV cars coming across from China. They all have style.

Now you might not like that style. Some of them might look ugly to you, and I'm on record as describing the two CV, the new one, as having the face only a mother could love. But it's undeniable they've taken some big design swings, more so in the case of the Jaguar and the Ferrari than the others mentioned here. Not all of them would be successful, but I warrant that the success is a function of the marketing and the functionality of the vehicle itself.

Rather than d the design. If it was a function of the design, the original 2CV, a car I will remind you, that was designed for rural French farmers and needed to be able to carry a carton of eggs, wouldn't have sold over five million in its production run, slightly fewer than the classic mini did. But let's leave design behind for a moment or two and look at another aspect of the e-design game that plays into this. Branding. Now, for many, many years, Mercedes.

Gary Comerford (:

Sold their cars in Europe using a specific naming convention. Cars were split into classes. You had the A-class, the E-class, the C class, the S-class. Now each was targeted at a different segment of the market. The cars themselves were not radically different in design. An E-Class Mercedes, a car in which I have ridden thousands of kilometers in Germany due to his extensive use as a taxi, is not radically different to an S-class. They are both recognizably Mercedes.

The same for BMW, they had the series cars, a three series, a five series, a seven series. The designs were similar. They all had the kidney air grills on the front, and a three series was smaller than a five series, which was smaller than a seven series. But you looked at one and it was obviously a BMW. Then the electric era came in, and these companies took a strategic decision, which was to produce a completely different line of vehicles for their electric range.

With Mercedes, they had the EQ vehicles. They were a different design, usually bigger and more SUV in style. BMW went for the I range. They started with the BMW I3, which bucks the trend of being a generic car and is something of a style icon. I'd love an I3 myself. But then they started producing cars that were distinctly different to the rest of the BMW range. People didn't want that. They wanted cars that looked

Like the 3 series and the 5 series and the 7 series that they had before. Instead, they got these lumbering iX series SUVs. Since then, though, BMW have moved back somewhat towards basing their designs on the original 3 or 5 or 7 series cars. So vehicles like the i4, i5, i7, for example. Volkswagen did something similar. They bifurcated, there's that word again.

They bifurcated their range into the original vehicles, the Golf, the Passat, the Tiguan, for example, and the ID range, which were totally different designs and treated as different cars. After seeing the impact this had on sales, coupled with some dodgy design choices made with things like haptic feedback buttons on the interior, they re-jig things and they seem to be moving back towards their original naming convention, with the introduction recently.

Gary Comerford (:

The ID Polo, which is a car that looks like the current VW Polo, but just happens to be electrified. Let's turn our attention finally to the outlier companies in the electric world, Honda and Nissan.

Gary Comerford (:

Both of these were pioneers in the electric car world in their with their earlier models.

Obviously, the Nissan Leaf was in iconic EV when it was launched. Quirky, stylish. I've got to say though I consider it ugly personally, but that's just my opinion. Honda brought out the Honda E, a lovely car with tons of personality and a great little design. Loved and adored by owners, but it didn't sell because it was overpriced for what it was and it had a low range and slow charging.

Both of these companies were at the forefront of EV design back in the day. Both of them fumbled that heavily. Nissan produced the ARIA, a very competent car that was just another bland SUV.

Honda produced the ENY1, the Any One, another SUV clone that was, by all accounts, a great EV if you could get one at a good price point. Neither set the EV world alight.

But they're both back. And guess what? They've brought quirky vehicles that don't look bland or unexciting.

Gary Comerford (:

Nissan has continued its linkage with Renault and produced the micro, which is basically a rebadged Renault 5 priced very, very similarly.

Gary Comerford (:

Honda has gone for the Honda Super N, which is a Korean K car style vehicle that looks completely different to other vehicles on the road at the moment.

Gary Comerford (:

Both are great design examples. Both of them are either beautiful or ugly depending on your aesthetic stance. Neither of them is bland or uninspiring or beige.

Gary Comerford (:

So what can we deduce from this? Well, there seems to be two different pressures acting on the car world at the moment.

Gary Comerford (:

There is the design aspect whereby many newer cars are coming across as generic and bland. And there's the differential factor whereby manufacturers are trying to differentiate their range by making electric cars a distinct brand. In both of these cases, there seems to be a push from the public to move away from those and provide a simple message. This is our range of cars. We've designed them all along similar lines. Some of them run electric drivetrains, others don't.

Gary Comerford (:

Time will peel will tell whether this approach will work. In the meantime, people are settling for some of the Far Eastern NEV models that are coming into the country: MG, Geely, BYD, ION, S Pen. All of these have ranges of vehicles that are selling well. But in and amongst these are some of the quirky vehicles that are attracting people's eyes, not because they're electric, but because they're interesting designs. There's a reason the two CVs sold well in France, and it's nothing to do with the performance.

Ditto the Renault 5. They were well designed. They were desirable. People wanted them. They didn't just want a small family hatchback, of which there were dozens around. They wanted a Renault 5 or a Peugeot 209 or a Golf GTI, style icons themselves. I think the shift is coming to the cars in Europe and the UK. With some of the newer cars being brought into the market, we're finding that the desirability factor is increasing a lot.

People want the Honda Super N. People want the Renault 5 and the Renault 4. These are not expensive cars. The Super N is under 20,000. The Renault 5 starts at 21,500 and the 4 at 23,500. And just to put this into context, I was at the Paris Motor Show recently and I saw the 50th anniversary Golf GTI for sale. It was 59,000 euros for a Golf GTI.

So where does this leave us all? Well, I think we were in danger of letting a lot of Far Eastern cars come in and take over the style aesthetic of EVs. They're bringing in competent, well-made, well-appointed vehicles that are, to my mind, tending to be moving towards a level of homogeneity that was edging towards blandness. On the other hand, there are some European vehicles that are trying to bug the trend and appeal to the design aspects of buyers rather than the functional aspects. As long as the pricing can keep up with them,

I think we'll have an interesting battle on our hands. What do you think? Let me know in the comments. That's our show for this week, and I hope you enjoyed listening to it. Now, if you've reached this part of the project, if you've reached this part of the podcast and are still listening, thank you. Why not let me know you've got to this point by messaging me at musingtv.bsky.social or leaving a comment in the YouTube below with the words fugly. Hashtag if you know you know, nothing else.

Gary Comerford (:

And thanks as always to my co-founder Simon. You know, he also faces the ugly versus bland dilemma, like many of us. Thanks for listening now. Bye bye.

About the Podcast

Show artwork for The EV Musings Podcast
The EV Musings Podcast
EV Musings - a podcast about electric vehicles.

About your host

Profile picture for Gary Comerford

Gary Comerford

Gary has almost 30 years experience working with, primarily, US multinationals. Then he gave it all up to do his own thing and now works in film and television, driving and advocating for electric vehicles and renewables, and hosting the EV Musings Podcast.